Immersive training, meaning VR, AR and mixed reality, is as effective as traditional training in the research, not clearly better, and its real value is in situations where danger or cost make traditional methods impractical. For industrial automation that points to a split: simulation without headsets is enough to learn PLC logic, while headsets earn their place in safety rehearsals, plant familiarisation and guided maintenance. This article sets out the evidence, the limits and what each approach costs, and is plain about what EDWartens uses.
Does VR training work for industrial automation?
Sometimes, and mostly by matching the tool to the task. The best summary of the field is a 2021 meta-analysis in the journal Human Factors by Kaplan and colleagues, which pooled empirical studies of transfer of training from VR, AR and MR. It found that training in extended reality does not produce a different outcome from training in a non-simulated control environment: it is equally effective. The authors conclude that the value of these tools lies in providing training in circumstances that exclude traditional methods, such as when danger or cost makes them impossible.
Individual studies add useful caution.
| Study | What it tested | Finding | Caveat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kaplan et al. (2021), Human Factors | Meta-analysis of transfer of training from VR, AR and MR | Equally effective as traditional training | Pooled across many fields, not only industrial automation |
| Makransky, Terkildsen and Mayer (2019), Learning and Instruction | 52 university students learning a science lab simulation on a desktop screen or in a VR headset | VR raised presence (d = 1.30) but learners scored lower (d = 0.80) and showed higher EEG-measured cognitive load (d = 0.59) | Science content, not industrial; immersion can distract |
| Gavish et al. (2015), Interactive Learning Environments | 40 expert technicians training for an industrial assembly task with VR or AR versus controls | Fewer unsolved errors in the AR group than its control; no significant VR advantage over its control | Small sample; authors cite a ceiling effect for VR |
The pattern is consistent: immersion makes people feel present and engaged, but feeling present is not the same as learning more. AR guidance overlaid on real equipment looked more promising than fully virtual practice in the one industrial study above, and that is a small study.
Where do VR, AR and simulation genuinely help?
They help most where the real thing is dangerous, rare, expensive or impossible to repeat. In industrial automation that covers four areas.

- Safety procedures: rehearsing isolation and lock-out steps, emergency stops and hazard recognition without exposure to live energy.
- Fault finding that is too risky or costly to stage: a broken wire, a welded contactor or a failed sensor. A German research project funded by DGUV, called SafetySim, built a multi-user 3D training system in which trainees inject faults such as contact gaps, broken wires, welded contactors and short circuits and watch how a Safety PLC reacts. It was tested with Siemens S7-1200 Safety and an Eaton easy Safety PLC, and the project describes a 3D simulation running in real time on a standard PC. In other words, a high-value use of simulation does not require a headset.
- Spatial familiarisation: walking a large plant, finding isolation points and understanding cable routes before a site visit.
- Guided assembly and maintenance (AR): overlaying steps on real equipment, which is where the Gavish study saw its clearest benefit.
Simulation shares the same practical advantages that older VR articles credit to headsets: instant reset, unlimited repetition, scenarios from many industries and learners working at the same time from different places. Those advantages belong to simulation in general, not to VR specifically.
What does EDWartens actually use?
EDWartens' Professional Module is a five-day live online class taught by an instructor over Microsoft Teams, and its practical work uses simulation: Siemens PLCSIM, Factory I/O and the free browser labs at lab.edwartens.com. It does not use VR headsets. We say so plainly because older articles on this topic, including earlier versions of this one, suggested otherwise, and we would rather you choose a course on what it really includes.
Factory I/O deserves a clear description too. Its own site describes it as a 3D factory simulator for PLC training, where the software simulates the plant and your PLC runs the logic, connecting to S7-PLCSIM and PLCSIM Advanced, Allen-Bradley platforms, Modbus and OPC. We found no VR support in its documentation, and a Factory I/O community thread asking about VR headsets, with posts from September 2021 to October 2024, shows no reply from the vendor. Treat it as a desktop simulator.
How does simulation compare with VR and physical rigs?
Each approach has a job, and none replaces the others entirely.
| Factor | Browser or desktop simulation | VR or AR headset | Physical training rig |
|---|---|---|---|
| Learning PLC logic | Strong: the real program runs against a simulated plant | Adds little for logic itself | Strong, with real I/O |
| Fault injection | Easy and safe | Easy and safe, immersive | Limited by what can be staged safely |
| Wiring, torque, tools, real field noise | Cannot teach | Cannot teach beyond visualisation | Only way to practise |
| Access from home | Yes | Needs headset and content | No |
| Reset and repeat | Instant | Instant | Slow, needs supervision |
| Cost model | Free browser labs; Factory I/O editions from 158 euros a year (Siemens edition) or 435 euros one-time, per its website | Headsets plus content development and management; prices vary widely, so get quotes | Hardware, space, maintenance and an instructor |
Simulation shows that your logic works, but not that your wiring is right, your comms are healthy or your enclosure survives the real environment. Employers hiring junior controls staff want evidence you can reason about real machines, and a simulator-built portfolio is a good start, not a finish. Our guide to PLC training kits versus simulators goes deeper on that trade-off.
What are the limits and costs of VR training?
The honest limits are cognitive load, content cost and weak evidence on transfer. Makransky and colleagues found higher cognitive load and lower learning in VR for a science task. Custom industrial VR content has to be built, updated whenever equipment or procedures change, and checked for accuracy. Headsets need management, cleaning and a place to use them. And the evidence base for industrial VR specifically is thin: small studies, tabletop tasks and few long-term follow-ups.
None of that makes VR a bad idea. It makes it a targeted one: use it where a physical alternative is unsafe or prohibitively expensive, and use plain simulation for everything else.
How should you choose training?
Match the method to your goal, and ask providers for specifics.
- Learning to programme PLCs: pick a course with real simulation of the controller and a plant model, and enough instructor time.
- Safety-critical or hazardous-plant roles: look for VR or AR rehearsal alongside site-specific procedures, not instead of them.
- Questions to ask any provider: which simulator runs the real PLC program, what is practised on real hardware, how faults are practised, and what evidence supports claims of faster learning.
- Be sceptical of big numbers: percentages for faster learning or better retention need a named study. The meta-analysis above found parity, not large gains.
How EDWartens can help
The EDWartens Professional Module is a five-day live online class on Siemens TIA Portal, with simulation and testing in days one and two, HMI in day three and WinCC SCADA in days four and five, followed by self-paced Basic Engineering. It is simulation-based and does not include physical rigs or VR headsets. To try the approach free, use the browser PLC simulator and the Factory I/O virtual commissioning course, then see the Professional Module or sign up.




