PROFINET and EtherNet/IP are the two biggest industrial Ethernet protocols, and the right one to learn first is the one your target employers run. According to the HMS Networks 2025 market study, PROFINET accounted for 30% of new industrial network nodes worldwide and EtherNet/IP for 25%. PROFINET leads in Europe; EtherNet/IP is dominant in North America. In the UK you will meet both, so start with whichever matches your PLC platform.
How big is each protocol?
Both are growing and together they are about 55% of all new factory-automation nodes. HMS Networks, which publishes an annual study of new nodes, reported in 2026 that industrial Ethernet made up 79% of new nodes in 2025 (up from 76%), while fieldbus fell to 14%. Within Ethernet:
| Protocol | Share of new nodes, 2024 | Share of new nodes, 2025 | Where it leads |
|---|---|---|---|
| PROFINET | 27% | 30% | Europe, with strong growth in China |
| EtherNet/IP | 23% | 25% | North America, especially automotive and discrete manufacturing |
| EtherCAT | 17% | 20% | Motion and machine control |
| Modbus TCP | 5% | 5% | Simple, low-cost devices |
Source: HMS Networks via Drives & Controls, June 2026. These are global figures for new factory-automation nodes, not a UK survey. We could not find a published UK-only split, so the UK picture below comes from regional trends rather than a UK count.
PI separately reports PROFINET's installed base at 89.2 million nodes at the end of 2025.
How do the two protocols work?
The core difference is philosophy. PROFINET is a purpose-built real-time Ethernet standard with its own device model; EtherNet/IP puts the Common Industrial Protocol (CIP) on top of ordinary TCP/IP and UDP.
PROFINET exchanges cyclic I/O data using a real-time channel that can run on standard switches (RT), and offers IRT and TSN for tighter synchronisation. Devices are described by GSD files, and the controller assigns IP addresses through device names.
EtherNet/IP uses standard Ethernet and the TCP/IP suite. ODVA, which manages the standard, says EtherNet/IP also supports UDP for real-time cyclic data and runs on standard, unmodified Ethernet, so facilities do not need special hardware. CIP is a media-independent suite of messages and services covering control, safety, security, energy, synchronisation and motion. Wikipedia's summary of the technical detail: basic I/O data moves by UDP-based implicit messaging, while parameters, programs and recipes move by TCP explicit messaging.

What are the technical differences?
Both can control safety and motion on the same network as standard I/O. The differences are in how they get there.
| Feature | PROFINET | EtherNet/IP |
|---|---|---|
| Standards body | PI (PROFIBUS & PROFINET International) | ODVA |
| Application layer | PROFINET IO with GSD device descriptions | Common Industrial Protocol (CIP), EDS files |
| Real-time approach | RT on standard switches; IRT or TSN for synchronisation | UDP implicit messaging; CIP Sync (IEEE 1588) for timing |
| Motion control | IRT or TSN | CIP Motion: ODVA cites clock synchronisation better than 200 ns on standard Ethernet |
| Functional safety | PROFIsafe (31.5 million nodes installed by 2025, per PI) | CIP Safety: certified by TUV Rheinland as a "black channel" protocol, up to SIL 3 |
| Security | PROFINET V2.5 adds security mechanisms and certificate management | CIP Security |
| Redundancy | MRP rings; higher-end redundancy options | Device Level Ring (DLR) |
| IT/OT integration | Standard TCP/IP in parallel; OPC UA companion specification | Standard TCP/IP; OPC UA companion specification for CIP in development |
A note on motion: ODVA's approach is to let end devices synchronise their own clocks rather than demand a deterministic network, which is how it argues standard Ethernet can handle closed-loop drive control. PROFINET IRT reserves bandwidth in the network instead. Both work; they are engineered differently.
Which should I learn first?
Choose by PLC platform and region, not by a spec sheet.
- Learn PROFINET first if you are learning Siemens TIA Portal, want to work with S7-1200 or S7-1500 controllers, or are targeting employers across continental Europe. PROFINET is built into Siemens controllers and engineering.
- Learn EtherNet/IP first if you are learning Allen-Bradley (Rockwell) Studio 5000, targeting North American employers, or working on lines that use Rockwell drives and I/O.
- Learn both if you plan to be a systems integrator, commissioning engineer or consultant, or if your employer runs mixed plant. The concepts (topology, addressing, diagnostics, switch configuration) transfer; the engineering screens do not.
The honest UK answer is that it varies by site. Many plants have one dominant vendor and a few machines from OEMs that bring the other. Check the job adverts you want: if they say TIA Portal, S7-1500 or WinCC, that points to PROFINET; if they say Studio 5000 or ControlLogix, that points to EtherNet/IP.
What skills carry across both?
Most day-to-day network skill is protocol-neutral, which is why learning one properly makes the second easy.
- IP addressing and subnetting. Plan address ranges and avoid duplicates.
- Managed switches. VLANs, port statistics, mirroring, loop protection and ring redundancy.
- Cabling. Shielded cable, M12 connectors, grounding and bend radius.
- Packet capture. Wireshark decodes both protocols and settles arguments about what is on the wire.
- Segmentation and security. Separate OT and IT networks, as HMS notes that cybersecurity is now cited by nearly half of respondents as a top integration challenge.
How do they compare in redundancy, safety and security?
Both protocols have answers for each, with different names. For ring redundancy, PROFINET commonly uses the Media Redundancy Protocol, while EtherNet/IP commonly uses Device Level Ring, which ODVA lists among the topologies EtherNet/IP supports alongside star and linear. For functional safety, PROFIsafe and CIP Safety both run over the standard network without a separate safety cable: ODVA says CIP Safety can coexist with CIP Motion and CIP Security, and PI reports 31.5 million PROFIsafe nodes installed. For security, PI's V2.5 specification adds integrated security mechanisms, and ODVA says CIP Security supports a defence-in-depth approach that can help users comply with IEC 62443 and the EU Cyber Resilience Act.
What mistakes do beginners make?
- Treating the choice as a debate. Employers care that you can commission and diagnose a network, not that you have an opinion on which protocol is superior.
- Ignoring the basics. Duplicate IP addresses, wrong subnet masks and unmanaged switches cause more call-outs than protocol subtleties.
- Learning only the protocol, not the tool. Each vendor's engineering software has its own way of assigning names, addresses and parameters. Practise in the tool you will actually use.
- Skipping packet capture. A short Wireshark session often shows in minutes what hours of guessing does not.
How do you check what UK employers want?
Read ten adverts for the roles you want and count the platform names. Phrases such as TIA Portal, S7-1500, WinCC or PROFINET point to Siemens environments; Studio 5000, ControlLogix or CompactLogix point to Rockwell. Because we found no published UK-only protocol share, this bottom-up check is more reliable than any global statistic, and it also tells you which vendor's training to prioritise first.
What about EtherCAT and the others?
Do not ignore the third protocol. HMS Networks puts EtherCAT at 20% of new nodes in 2025, up from 17%, and it is common in motion and machine control, so you may meet it on OEM machines even in a Siemens or Rockwell plant. Modbus TCP, at 5%, is still the lingua franca for simple meters and third-party devices. The skills in this article, addressing, switching, diagnostics and security, carry across all of them.
How EDWartens can help
The EDWartens UK Professional Module is Siemens-focused: a five-day live online class in TIA Portal followed by self-paced Basic Engineering that includes industrial communication protocols. It does not cover Allen-Bradley or Studio 5000, so if EtherNet/IP is your main target, treat it as a complement. The course is online and simulation-based, and the CPD certificate is not a regulated qualification. For free practice, try the PLC simulator, the free Allen-Bradley Studio 5000 course and the PROFINET course. See also our Siemens vs Allen-Bradley comparison and the PROFINET design guide.




