Physical AIUpdated 21 October 20268 min read

Functional Safety: SIL vs Performance Level (PL) Explained

Functional safety is about making a safety function work correctly when needed. Machinery uses ISO 13849-1 Performance Levels (PL a to e) or IEC 62061 SILs (1 to 3); process plants use IEC 61511 under IEC 61508. PL e and SIL 3 both correspond to a dangerous failure rate from 10^-8 to below 10^-7 per hour.

Functional SafetySILPerformance LevelISO 13849-1IEC 62061Machine Safety
Orange industrial robot arm beside a conveyor in a university automation lab

Key takeaways

  • PL e (ISO 13849-1) and SIL 3 (IEC 62061) both correspond to 10^-8 to below 10^-7 dangerous failures per hour for high-demand safety functions.
  • ISO 13849-1:2023 is the fourth edition, published in April 2023, and replaced the 2015 edition.
  • IEC 62061:2021 cancelled the 2005 first edition and its two amendments, and shifted from SILCL to the maximum SIL of a subsystem.
  • IEC 61511-1:2016 is the process-sector implementation of IEC 61508:2010, not a machinery standard.
  • GOV.UK last updated its consolidated list of designated standards for machinery on 8 August 2026.
  • Siemens states its S7-1500 and ET 200MP fail-safe I/O modules can be used up to PL e / SIL 3.

Functional safety means that a safety function, such as an emergency stop or a guard interlock, performs correctly when it is needed, to a level of reliability matched to the risk. For machinery you choose between ISO 13849-1 (Performance Levels PL a to PL e) and IEC 62061 (Safety Integrity Levels SIL 1 to SIL 3); process plants use IEC 61511, itself an implementation of IEC 61508. For high-demand safety functions, PL e and SIL 3 both sit in the band of 10^-8 to below 10^-7 dangerous failures per hour. The older rule of thumb "SIL for process, PL for machines" is a simplification: both machinery standards are in current use, and the choice is made by the machine builder.

What is the difference between SIL and PL?

Both rate how reliably a safety function performs, but they come from different standards and use different methods. IEC 61508-1:2010 is the generic basic safety publication: it takes a risk-based approach, introduces safety integrity levels and, as the IEC says, does not itself specify the level required for any particular function. Sector standards then apply it. IEC 61511-1:2016 is the process-industry implementation for safety instrumented systems. IEC 62061:2021 is the machinery sector standard within the IEC 61508 framework; its scope is control systems for machines in high or continuous demand mode, and the IEC notes this edition extends it to non-electrical technologies and moves from "SILCL" to the "maximum SIL" of a subsystem. ISO 13849-1:2023 (fourth edition, published April 2023) specifies a methodology for the design and integration of safety-related parts of control systems of any technology, for high demand and continuous modes, and ISO says it does not specify which safety functions or required performance levels apply in a given application.

FeatureISO 13849-1:2023IEC 62061:2021IEC 61511
Rating scalePL a to PL eSIL 1 to SIL 3SIL, set within the IEC 61508 framework
SectorMachineryMachineryProcess industry
TechnologyAny (electrical, hydraulic, pneumatic, mechanical)Electrical and, in the 2021 edition, non-electricalSafety instrumented systems
Demand modeHigh demand and continuous (not low demand)High and continuous demandSafety instrumented systems; see the standard
Parent standardRefers to the IEC 61508 series for low-demand modeSector standard within IEC 61508Process sector implementation of IEC 61508

How do the PL and SIL numbers line up?

They line up by probability of dangerous failure per hour (PFHd). SICK's guide to performance levels lists PL a as 10^-5 up to 10^-4 per hour, PL b from 3 x 10^-6 to below 10^-5, PL d from 10^-7 to below 10^-6, and PL e from 10^-8 to below 10^-7 (PL c sits between b and d). A Siemens help document for IEC 62061 lists SIL 3 as 10^-8 to below 10^-7, SIL 2 as 10^-7 to below 10^-6, and SIL 1 as 10^-6 to below 10^-5. So, broadly, PL e matches SIL 3, PL d matches SIL 2, and PL b and PL c both fall inside the SIL 1 band. The match is on the failure-rate band only. Each standard has its own architecture, diagnostic coverage, common-cause failure and systematic-integrity requirements, so you cannot declare a PL from a SIL, or the reverse, by looking at the number.

Red emergency stop button with yellow collar on a machine control panel
Red emergency stop button with yellow collar on a machine control panelPhoto: Flygklubben, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Machine safety is a legal requirement; the standards are the usual way of showing you have met it. In Great Britain the Supply of Machinery (Safety) Regulations 2008 apply to supplying machinery, not the EU Machinery Directive itself. GOV.UK publishes the list of designated standards for machinery, updated most recently on 8 August 2026, and its UKCA guidance says machinery outside the higher-risk list in Schedule 2, Part 4 can be self-declared, as can machinery in that list where all relevant designated standards are applied in full and cover all applicable essential requirements. Users of machinery have duties under PUWER 1998 as well. Whether a particular edition of ISO 13849-1 or IEC 62061 is designated, and what that means for your product, needs checking against the current gov.uk consolidated list or with a conformity assessor; this is general information, not legal advice.

What does the safety lifecycle look like?

Both families follow the same logic: understand the hazard, define the function, design, verify, validate, and keep it working. In practice, for each safety function you write down:

  1. Hazard and risk assessment, ending in a required PL (PLr) or SIL.
  2. Safety requirements specification: what triggers it, what safe state it reaches, how fast.
  3. Architecture and component selection: sensor, logic, final element (contactor or drive), with PFHd data from the manufacturers and a calculation of the whole chain.
  4. Implementation: wiring, safety logic, parameters.
  5. Verification and validation: test the function and the failure responses against the specification.
  6. Operation: proof testing, inspection and controlled change. IEC 62061:2021 added requirements on periodic testing and expanded requirements on parameterisation.

Which safety functions do automation engineers meet most often?

Emergency stop, guard door monitoring, light curtains and scanners, two-hand control, safe speed monitoring and safe torque off (STO) on drives are the staples. IEC 60204-1:2016 reorganised its clause on safe torque off, emergency stop and control circuit protection, so the electrical build and the safety design need to agree. For robots and cells, see our robot and PLC integration guide.

Demystifying Functional Safety: SIS, SIL, and MooN Explained

How do safety PLCs fit in?

A safety PLC runs standard and safety programs in one controller, but the safety side has extra discipline. Siemens states that all its S7-1500 and ET 200MP fail-safe I/O modules can be used in applications up to PL e / SIL 3, integrated over PROFIsafe on PROFINET or PROFIBUS. Siemens' programming guideline for S7-1200/1500 adds the working rules: the safety program has signatures that identify its state, a changed signature means the safety program has to be validated again and accepted, and changes to the safety program are reserved for users with the safety password. A passed signature check is evidence for validation, not a replacement for it, and the chosen PL or SIL still depends on the entire safety function, not the controller alone.

ISO 13849 Explained – Functional Safety of Machinery

What does a worked safety-function example look like?

Take a guard door on a packing machine that must stop a motor when opened. The risk assessment decides how severe, how frequent and how avoidable an injury would be, and that yields a required performance level, say PL d. You then choose a door switch with safety contacts, a safety relay or fail-safe input, and a contactor pair or a drive with safe torque off, each with manufacturer PFHd or B10d data. The architecture, diagnostic coverage and common-cause measures are assessed for the chain as a whole; if the calculated PL is below the required PL, you improve the weakest element rather than arguing with the number. Finally you test the function: open the door with the machine running, check the stop time, and check what happens on a wiring fault, because the failure response is part of what you validate. Free tools such as SISTEMA are widely used for the PL calculation, and the free course linked below shows the method.

How EDWartens can help

EDWartens UK does not teach safety PLC programming or functional safety calculations. The Professional Module is a five-day live online Siemens TIA Portal class (PLC, HMI, WinCC SCADA) plus self-paced Basic Engineering, whose video modules include safety and standards. It costs £2,140 + VAT (£2,568), runs weekly from Monday with up to 10 learners, and comes with a CPD certificate recording 80 hours of learning; it is not a regulated qualification. For a free start on this topic, EDWartens' sister site offers a machine safety course covering ISO 13849 and SISTEMA. Safety design should be done by or under a competent safety engineer. You can sign up here.

Start free

Learn PLC programming free, then practise the job

Free job simulation

PLC Programmer

Write the I/O list, program the line, run the FAT and handle a change request.

The first five days are free, no card needed.

Live UK jobs

PLC and automation jobs in the UK

Updated daily, with licensed visa sponsors marked.

Browse all engineering jobs

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between SIL and Performance Level?

Both rate how reliably a safety function performs. SIL comes from IEC 61508 and its sector standards, including IEC 62061 for machinery and IEC 61511 for process plants; PL comes from ISO 13849-1 for machinery. Their failure-rate bands line up (PL e with SIL 3), but each standard has its own architecture and systematic requirements.

Is PL e the same as SIL 3?

They share the same dangerous-failure-rate band, 10^-8 to below 10^-7 per hour, but they are not interchangeable. Achieving PL e needs ISO 13849-1 requirements for architecture, diagnostics and common-cause failure; SIL 3 needs IEC 62061 or IEC 61508 requirements. A product certified to one is not automatically compliant with the other.

Which standard should I use for machine safety in the UK?

Either ISO 13849-1 or IEC 62061 can be used for the safety-related control system of machinery; many designers use ISO 13849-1 for simpler architectures and IEC 62061 where SIL-based tools are preferred. In Great Britain, check the gov.uk designated standards list and take advice from a conformity assessor on which edition applies.

What is a safety function?

A safety function is a defined action that reduces risk, for example stopping a motor when a guard door opens. It includes the sensor, the logic and the final element, such as a contactor or drive with safe torque off. Its required integrity is set by risk assessment and then verified for the whole chain.

Can I learn functional safety on the EDWartens course?

Not in depth. The Professional Module focuses on Siemens TIA Portal PLC, HMI and WinCC SCADA, and its self-paced Basic Engineering includes safety and standards modules. EDWartens' sister site has a free machine safety course on ISO 13849 and SISTEMA, but safety design needs competent practitioners and the standards themselves.

Sources

  1. IEC 61508-1:2010 (IEC Webstore)
  2. IEC 61511-1:2016 (IEC Webstore)
  3. IEC 62061:2021 (IEC Webstore)
  4. ISO 13849-1:2023 Safety of machinery, safety-related parts of control systems (ISO)
  5. What are performance levels? (SICK)
  6. Help on the Application of IEC 62061, Safety Evaluation with TIA Selection Tool (Siemens)
  7. SIMATIC Safety Integrated (Siemens brochure)
  8. Programming Guideline Safety for SIMATIC S7-1200/1500 (Siemens)
  9. IEC 60204-1:2016+AMD1:2021 (IEC Webstore)
  10. The Supply of Machinery (Safety) Regulations 2008 (legislation.gov.uk)
  11. Designated standards: machinery (GOV.UK)
  12. Using the UKCA marking (GOV.UK)

Share this article

About the author

EDWartens Team

EDWartens Instructional Team

The EDWartens instructional team brings together UK-based automation engineers, certified Siemens and Rockwell specialists, and industry practitioners with decades of combined experience in PLC programming, SCADA engineering, and industrial AI.

View all articles by EDWartens

Ready to become job-ready?

Start with a free course today, or train live in Siemens PLC, HMI and SCADA on the Professional Module.

Related articles

Career

Funded PLC Training in England: What Exists in 2026

Public funding in England mostly attaches to regulated qualifications at approved colleges, not short private courses. Free Courses for Jobs covers adults aged 19+ earning under £25,750 or unemployed; Advanced Learner Loans cover Level 3 to 6; apprenticeships pay you to learn. EDWartens' private course is not eligible for loan or bootcamp funding. Rules checked 21 October 2026.

Read article
Physical AI

Electrical Safety in Industrial Automation: UK Law and Standards

In Great Britain, electrical safety in automation work rests on the Electricity at Work Regulations 1989: systems must be safe, equipment must be isolable, live work needs strict justification, and people must be competent. HSE says it is never absolutely safe to work on live equipment. This is guidance, not legal advice.

Read article
Career

Best Certifications for Automation Engineers (UK, 2026)

The most useful automation credentials depend on your platform and role: a vendor certificate (Siemens or Rockwell), ISA CAP or CCST, TÜV functional safety engineer, CompEx for hazardous areas, or UK registration as EngTech, IEng or CEng. This guide describes each from the awarding body's own pages.

Read article
Career

50 PLC Interview Questions and Answers (UK, 2026)

A working question bank of 50 PLC and automation interview questions with short, technically checked answers, grouped by topic: fundamentals, Siemens, Rockwell, SCADA, networks, safety and behavioural. Siemens appears in 11.8% of UK PLC engineer adverts on ITJobsWatch and Rockwell in 5.6%, so both are covered.

Read article